Doug's Darkworld

War, Science, and Philosophy in a Fractured World.

Cougars to Korans to American Exceptionalism, Straw Vulcan Logic Illustrated

with 5 comments

Is that a lovely? That’s California Fish and Game Commission President Daniel Richards posing with a cougar he recently killed in Idaho. He claims it was in self defence. OK, that was a joke. He killed (and reportedly ate) the cougar in a  perfectly legal hunt in Idaho. This has caused a storm of protest and calls for his resignation in California, where such hunts are illegal. Mr Richards says the hunt was legal, it was on his own time, and is no different than, say, any other California state official travelling to Nevada to go gambling, which is also illegal in California. So what’s the problem?

The problem is that Mr Richards is an insensitive  idiot. Now don’t get me wrong, I support hunting and fishing when well regulated, the alternative is much uglier. And while I’m not a big fan of trophy hunting, within reason I don’t have a problem with it. I would prefer that trophy hunters be limited to hand weapons like spears and knives. I mean come on guys, if you have to kill a big animal to prove you have stones, do it like a man. Any  a**hat can shoot a cat in a tree. Bring down a cougar or  a bear with a spear, and I’ll buy you a drink dude. Or have one in your memory at least.

I digress. Suffice it to say that any state official careless enough to allow a public picture of himself grinning like a loon while he pursues an activity that the majority of his employers disagree with, an activity he is sworn to prevent in his state, is an idiot. Yes, as a state official he is working for the voters of California. That he doesn’t understand, or is pretending not to understand, that letting a picture like this hit the airwaves would cause some major backlash, is mind blowing to me.

The point here, is that Mr Richard’s attitude is an excellent example of Vulcan logic. Because what he did was legal, he’s basically claiming that anyone who gets upset isn’t being logical, therefore he can ignore them. People do react emotionally to stuff, and anyone who has lived on Earth for more than a few weeks should understand that. Anyone who completely disregarded the emotions of people in their personal life pretty quickly wouldn’t have any friends, or at least they would have just strange stunted friendships. Now for the record I am not saying that every time someone gets upset at a public official’s actions it means they were wrong. I am saying that to claim that your actions are defensible because “people shouldn’t rationally get upset by this” is in and of itself a profoundly irrational argument. People are creatures of emotion, and to pretend otherwise isn’t rational.

And we come to a similar situation in Afghanistan. Despite the fact that there is ample evidence that defacing the Koran violates a core value of many or most of the Afghan people, many Americans in and out of politics and the media act surprised every time something like this happens and cluck cluck about how “irrational” their response is. With simply zero empathy for how they would respond in a  similar situation. If a Muslim Army had occupied the USA for a decade, waging war against the Tea Party the whole time, and the charred remains of the Star Spangled Banner flag was found in a  trash pit outside a Saudi military base, many Americans would go ballistic. The point is that the burning of the Korans, and allowing Afghans to find out, was a sign of either mind numbing incompetence on the part of some Americans … or mind numbing indifference.

The meta point I am dancing around here is that the attitude of many Americans about this Koran issue is simply a reflection of the fact that they think we are the good guys with the superior values, and our values trump theirs. This is the colonial mind set or cultural imperialism or American exceptionalism … or just plain old fashioned being arrogant and condescending. Claiming one is “helping” people by invading their country and installing a government of our liking is bizarre enough, claiming that trampling on their values at the same time is “no big deal” is beyond bizarre, it’s insane.

And frankly, my current theory is that imperialism is a disease. And the USA has a raging case of it.

(The above image is claimed as Fair Use under US copyright law. It’s not being used for profit and at this point is definitely an historically important image. My opinion on the topic? I say to Mr Richards: “Good shot! However, this picture shows you are too stupid, arrogant, and insensitive to hold public office, do us all a favour and resign.”)

PS: Have a great weekend everyone!


5 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. Standing ovation!! I love this article maybe because I agree with everything you said. Enjoy your weekend!

    Carol Day

    March 2, 2012 at 11:27 am

  2. Well said.. well said.

    This guy should be ‘promoted’ to the basement of his building. He serves the Governor and is non-represented. He is an ‘at-will’ employee and the governor could fire him for any reason he chooses, including not having one.

    That being said is it any wonder these guys (and gals) turn up in high places? A sociopathic streak is in most of them.

    John Galt

    March 2, 2012 at 3:53 pm

  3. It gets uglier, an ethics complaint has been filed against him since he didn’t pay for the hunt and didn’t report it as a gift as he was required by law to do so. And it’s well above the limit on legal gifts to public officials.


    March 2, 2012 at 7:15 pm

  4. At one time the military police in the USAF were Security Police or for short “SP’s”. The joke was “you cant Spell Stupid without SP”. Well in this case you cant spell Dumb Retard without DR (Daniel Richards) As for our Military and Koran burning, uh well DRs again. Did Obama order the USAF to burn Korans so he’d have an excuse to continue an illegal war? Speaking of illegals, how can we the USA worry about illegals like Mexicans here in the USA, when we are illegally in Iraq (War of Aggression in violation of the UN charter. We need to get the beam (Iraq war) out of our own eye before we worry about the mote (Mexicans) in the worlds eye. Okay I digressed and wandered sorrrreeee! Re this part: “Anyone who completely disregarded the emotions of people in their personal life pretty quickly wouldn’t have any friends, or at least they would have just strange stunted friendships”. Sounds like a Vietnam Vet. I ought to know, I am one. Seriously short of friends and don’t give a rats ass that I am. I should have gone to Canada.

    Wade O Kane

    March 4, 2012 at 12:11 am

  5. American Exceptionalism is the puffery used to excuse misadventure abroad and inaction at home. In a recent post I analyze the American Exceptionalism concept and contrast it with a healthy patriotism that could help unite the public against those few who are ruining America.


    March 6, 2012 at 11:58 am

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: